Discussion about this post

User's avatar
shieldmaidenpdx's avatar

Interesting thoughts on the word viking! Judith is, of course, correct. All words can change in use and meaning over time, and 'viking' is no different. For me, if someone is really interested in actual vikings, the important thing to try and understand is whether and how THEY used the word in THEIR own time, i.e., during the Viking Age. That's really all that matters because, despite some people's wishes to the contrary, vikings don't exist anymore. Anyone interested in this should check out Judith's 2001 book Ships and Men in the Late Viking Age: The Vocabulary of Runic Inscriptions and Skaldic Verse. In it she discusses the original sources -- runic inscriptions and skaldic poems -- where the word viking is found, and which variously seem to have meant an activity (piracy), the person doing that activity, or sometimes used to describe a member of an in-group but more often seems to have been a pejorative directed toward an outsider.

Additionally, look at the languages used then. In Old Icelandic for instance, the dialect of Old Norse spoken in the Viking Age in Iceland, the word víkingr was used to describe a “freebooter, sea-rover, pirate” -- again a person doing a particular activity. So, the "it's a job" people are not far off the mark. I would also argue that there is consensus, to the extent that it matters, that 'viking' is not an ethnic classification.

Lastly, I'd urge caution in saying we can make words mean whatever we want as long as we can define what we mean when using them first. As you say in this post, someone's definition can frame how the word is being interpreted, which is certainly true, but that does not, ergo, mean they are using the word correctly. At least in the scholarly community I do think we have a general sense of what we mean when we say viking; it's not wide open. And I think we do have to agree there are some objective truths to words and their meanings that are not changeable simply based on who is able to create a definition; the incorrect ethnic classification of 'viking' is a good case in point. If that's not the case, and words can be manipulated so easily, then I'm afraid we'll all be living in an Orwellian nightmare pretty quickly.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts